Home > Montecristo Cigars > Montecristo Connoisseur Edition New York No. 2

Montecristo Connoisseur Edition New York No. 2

This box-pressed torpedo from the Big Apple makes its presence known with a 54-ring gauge and 6⅛" length. Dark Habano wrapper glistens with oil - the kind that stains your fingers just from looking at it. At $15.58 per stick in 10-count boxes, it's priced like a premium player but smokes like a workhorse.

Key Specs

  • Brand: Montecristo
  • Price: $155.82/box
  • Count: 10 cigars
  • Size: 6⅛" x 54
  • Shape: Box-Pressed Figurado
  • Strength: Medium (★★★☆☆)

Smoke Breakdown

First Third: Initial draws release sweet cedar and baking spices - think nutmeg-dusted coffee cake. Smoke production stays medium, no chimney effect here. The square press feels good between lips but requires more frequent rotation while burning.

Mid Section: Dominican fillers show their age with developed cocoa notes. Earthiness creeps in around the 40-minute mark, pairing oddly well with the citrus tang from the Nicaraguan binder. Ash holds tight in 1-inch segments.

Final Stretch: Last third brings black pepper and leather without turning harsh. Retrohale reveals hidden floral notes - maybe the "NY sophistication" they advertise. Need to purge twice in final 15 minutes as tar builds up.

Cigar Comparisons

  • Partagás Serie P No.2: Same torpedo shape, stronger earth profile (6.1"x52)
  • Romeo Wide Churchill: Rounder format, creamier smoke (5.1"x55)
  • H. Upmann Magnum 54: Similar ring gauge, brighter citrus notes (5.7"x54)
  • Arturo Fuente Opus X: Higher complexity, Dominican puro (Various sizes)

Real Talk

The box press helps maintain structural integrity but slows combustion - plan for 90+ minute sessions. While marketed as "New York exclusive," the flavor profile leans classic Dominican with Cuban-style twang. Good option for travelers who want Montecristo pedigree without Havana sticker shock. Box recommendation: Buy 1 to smoke now, 1 to age - these develop interesting raisin notes after 18+ months.

Related to recommend

    Price: $160.62

    160.62

    Price: $180.65

    180.65

    Price: $220.37

    220.37

    Price: $210.58

    210.58

    Price: $172.80

    172.80