Let's cut through the hype on this 5x60 box-pressed Nicaraguan beast retailing at $275.31/23ct. The Judge Grand Robusto demands attention with its dense roll and dark Ecuador Sumatra wrapper glistening with oil. Designed for full-bodied enthusiasts, this cigar packs Garcia family-grown tobaccos from Estelí and Jalapa into a slow-burning 90+ minute session. Box-pressing ensures perfect draw control despite the massive 60 ring gauge.
Cold draw releases damp earth and bitter cocoa. Initial puffs deliver black pepper through the nose with heavy espresso grounds on the tongue. Smoke output surprises - thick plumes despite tight roll. Watch the burn line - needs one correction in first inch. Ash holds firm for 1.5" before dropping.
Pepper transitions to baking spices as charred oak emerges. Leathery texture coats the palate with each draw. Nicaraguan twang becomes pronounced - that distinct mineral tang from Estelí soil. Retrohale now shows dark cherry underneath the coffee base. Burn evens out beautifully after initial correction.
Nicotine kick becomes noticeable at band removal. Flavors concentrate into burnt caramel and bitter chocolate with lingering black pepper. Last inch develops subtle ammonia despite good construction - common in high-nicotine cigars. Smoke time varies: 1:30hrs if nursed, 1hr when puffing normally.
Handrolled in Estelí using García family tobaccos exclusively. The box-press eliminates typical 60rg airflow issues - draw remains open despite density. Triple cap withstands multiple cuts. Wrapper veins minimal but present - no structural weak points observed in sampled boxes.
Dry-box for 12hrs before smoking - reduces initial peppery punch. Pair with espresso or aged rum to complement the dark flavors. Not recommended after heavy meals - the nicotine content demands respect.
