Let's talk about the EP Carrillo Encore El Primero - a box-pressed Nicaraguan puro that comes in at 6⅞" with a 54 ring gauge. Priced at $256.50 for 20 cigars, this medium-full smoke won Cigar Aficionado's 2018 Top Cigar honor for good reason. The reddish-brown wrapper glistens with oil, begging to be lit.
The initial third hits with black pepper spice that quickly settles into caramelized walnut notes. Midway through, expect dark chocolate undertones mingling with leather and espresso - typical Nicaraguan earthiness kept in check by perfect combustion. Final third brings mineral notes reminiscent of Estelí volcanic soil, with lingering cedar sweetness.
The box-press feels substantial without being rigid. Triple-seam cap holds firm during punch cut. Burn line stays razor-sharp for first two-thirds before needing minor touch-ups - typical for thick-ring gauges. Average smoke time clocks 1hr 40min.
Smoked fresh from box: 8/10. Rest 6 months in 65% humidity and watch the harsh edges soften into honeycomb texture. After 18 months, develops subtle baking spice notes that complement the core profile beautifully.
